![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
beer_good_foamyThoughts on some series I've been watching recently.
Agent Carter, season 2
Was it just me, or did it feel like the writers were just as surprised as everyone else that they actually got a season 2? There's great stuff here, to be sure; Mrs Jarvis, the various jabs at Hollywood ("A movie based on a comic book? Sounds like a dreadful idea!"), the continuing worrying at various gender/racial divides that weren't quite as glossed over as they are today... We arguably get a better villain this season for that very reason; Whitney Frost deciding she'd rather be a monster with agency than a woman without is a story we don't see often, and it really worked well. Especially with the Hollywood backdrop (including the bit where the Marvel narrative smacks Frost down easily, because in this story women don't get to do that) and that final scene.
At the same time, though, it felt like the central characters didn't fare quite as well. While both Peggy, Daniel and Thompson get a lot to do, and Dottie is a lot of creepy fun, the stakes seem lower; season 1 had a place in the MCU, it covered backstory that fit in. Season 2, even when it's very good, feels like it's treading water; nothing that happens in it will have an effect on the story at large. Which may be why Peggy's storyline leans so heavily on Choosing The Right Man, and Daniel's fiancée is introduced only to be suddenly written off. Don't get me wrong, I love to see her moving on from moping over Captain Cardboard, but... well...
(Also, I miss Angie. Or at least mention of her outside a quick cameo.)
Eh. It's still one of the best parts of the MCU, Hayley Atwell and Enver Gjokaj are awesome, I really like the period setting, and I'd much rather watch season 3 than any of the upcoming movies. But speaking of the MCU...
Agents of SHIELD, 3.11
That was... actually pretty good? I've never been a huge fan of the series, but since the end of s1 it's at least been solidly competent. The mid-season finale left me a bit conflicted; Yes, they finally killed off Ward, only to bring him back as a zombie. Does Brett Dalton have compromising pictures of Stan Lee or something? But I liked that this episode got to introduce a new inhuman - and, considering the history of the show, a non-American non-English-speaking woman of colour, at that - who wasn't either killed off, imprisoned, depowered or joined our heroes, but got to have her own valid story independent of SHIELD. I'm sure this, along with their new presidential seal of approval, will all play into the civil war thing and I'll end up hating it, but for now it at least feels like the show is playing fair. Also, I liked the bonding moments between Coulson & May and Fitz & Simmons. But speaking of civil wars...
The 100
I'm done, I'm out, I'm gone. The 100 was always an uneven show, but when it was good, it really delivered in a very Buffy-like way; unprepared people having to deal with more than they can deal with, with no obvious "right" solutions. The main problem this season has been that they've introduced not just one but two new storylines - an AI storyline copied from BSG, and a story in which a genocidal maniac takes over leadership - that feel much too forced, where characters make stupid decisions for no other reason but to serve a plot that doesn't work.
And then, they kill off one of the series' best characters, and the fandom rightly revolts. I completely sympathize with those who are furious that yet another gay character gets killed off, seemingly because they're gay. But adding even more to that: It's so badly written - Lexa's death seems to check every single box on the cliché list, and partly feels like an exact carbon copy of Tara's death on BtVS, except without even the payoff of getting to see Warren pay for it. If they wanted to kill her off, it's not like they lacked opportunity to do it in a way that would have served the character; instead, they take a character who had been fighting her entire life, who faced death on her own terms on a daily basis, and kill her in a stupid accident where she gets no say at all except to blithely declare that she's at peace before dying. (How about just once, a non-villainous character gets to be, I dunno, furious or terrified or sad at their own death?) This, of course, is because it's so obviously done to sell the audience on the other two storylines that don't work. They even have a character literally cut Lexa's corpse open to reduce her to a plot point in the AI storyline, for fuck's sake, and I'll bet any amount you want that Clarke will get on board with the City of Light thing just so she can meet Lexa again.
The 100 always had problems, and it was never nearly as brave and subversive as it liked to pretend, but that was the final straw for me. A show must be allowed to kill off characters, whatever their demographics, even if it hurts. But when you do it as a substitute for knowing how to write a convincing plot with recognizable characters, when you sacrifice the good parts of the story hoping to make the bad ones suck less, I reserve the right to jump ship. And speaking of being disgusted...
It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia, season 11
No show should ever run for 11 seasons. That said, the Gang still manage to wring humour from utterly despicable characters for another round. They've got their character dynamics down so well they can plop them into any plot - this season, including an 80s college comedy and a courtroom drama - and just let them wreak havoc on each other. The shtick is old and we know what's coming, but in a world where Full House gets rebooted, I'm glad IASIP exists to remind us that sitcoms were always just 22-minute slices of sociopathy.
Plus, y'know, if you're going to satirize Trump, do it right.
Oh well. Bring on Game of Thrones and Daredevil. (Has anyone written a Weredevil AU? I'd be disappointed with fandom otherwise.)
Agent Carter, season 2
Was it just me, or did it feel like the writers were just as surprised as everyone else that they actually got a season 2? There's great stuff here, to be sure; Mrs Jarvis, the various jabs at Hollywood ("A movie based on a comic book? Sounds like a dreadful idea!"), the continuing worrying at various gender/racial divides that weren't quite as glossed over as they are today... We arguably get a better villain this season for that very reason; Whitney Frost deciding she'd rather be a monster with agency than a woman without is a story we don't see often, and it really worked well. Especially with the Hollywood backdrop (including the bit where the Marvel narrative smacks Frost down easily, because in this story women don't get to do that) and that final scene.
At the same time, though, it felt like the central characters didn't fare quite as well. While both Peggy, Daniel and Thompson get a lot to do, and Dottie is a lot of creepy fun, the stakes seem lower; season 1 had a place in the MCU, it covered backstory that fit in. Season 2, even when it's very good, feels like it's treading water; nothing that happens in it will have an effect on the story at large. Which may be why Peggy's storyline leans so heavily on Choosing The Right Man, and Daniel's fiancée is introduced only to be suddenly written off. Don't get me wrong, I love to see her moving on from moping over Captain Cardboard, but... well...
(Also, I miss Angie. Or at least mention of her outside a quick cameo.)
Eh. It's still one of the best parts of the MCU, Hayley Atwell and Enver Gjokaj are awesome, I really like the period setting, and I'd much rather watch season 3 than any of the upcoming movies. But speaking of the MCU...
Agents of SHIELD, 3.11
That was... actually pretty good? I've never been a huge fan of the series, but since the end of s1 it's at least been solidly competent. The mid-season finale left me a bit conflicted; Yes, they finally killed off Ward, only to bring him back as a zombie. Does Brett Dalton have compromising pictures of Stan Lee or something? But I liked that this episode got to introduce a new inhuman - and, considering the history of the show, a non-American non-English-speaking woman of colour, at that - who wasn't either killed off, imprisoned, depowered or joined our heroes, but got to have her own valid story independent of SHIELD. I'm sure this, along with their new presidential seal of approval, will all play into the civil war thing and I'll end up hating it, but for now it at least feels like the show is playing fair. Also, I liked the bonding moments between Coulson & May and Fitz & Simmons. But speaking of civil wars...
The 100
I'm done, I'm out, I'm gone. The 100 was always an uneven show, but when it was good, it really delivered in a very Buffy-like way; unprepared people having to deal with more than they can deal with, with no obvious "right" solutions. The main problem this season has been that they've introduced not just one but two new storylines - an AI storyline copied from BSG, and a story in which a genocidal maniac takes over leadership - that feel much too forced, where characters make stupid decisions for no other reason but to serve a plot that doesn't work.
And then, they kill off one of the series' best characters, and the fandom rightly revolts. I completely sympathize with those who are furious that yet another gay character gets killed off, seemingly because they're gay. But adding even more to that: It's so badly written - Lexa's death seems to check every single box on the cliché list, and partly feels like an exact carbon copy of Tara's death on BtVS, except without even the payoff of getting to see Warren pay for it. If they wanted to kill her off, it's not like they lacked opportunity to do it in a way that would have served the character; instead, they take a character who had been fighting her entire life, who faced death on her own terms on a daily basis, and kill her in a stupid accident where she gets no say at all except to blithely declare that she's at peace before dying. (How about just once, a non-villainous character gets to be, I dunno, furious or terrified or sad at their own death?) This, of course, is because it's so obviously done to sell the audience on the other two storylines that don't work. They even have a character literally cut Lexa's corpse open to reduce her to a plot point in the AI storyline, for fuck's sake, and I'll bet any amount you want that Clarke will get on board with the City of Light thing just so she can meet Lexa again.
The 100 always had problems, and it was never nearly as brave and subversive as it liked to pretend, but that was the final straw for me. A show must be allowed to kill off characters, whatever their demographics, even if it hurts. But when you do it as a substitute for knowing how to write a convincing plot with recognizable characters, when you sacrifice the good parts of the story hoping to make the bad ones suck less, I reserve the right to jump ship. And speaking of being disgusted...
It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia, season 11
No show should ever run for 11 seasons. That said, the Gang still manage to wring humour from utterly despicable characters for another round. They've got their character dynamics down so well they can plop them into any plot - this season, including an 80s college comedy and a courtroom drama - and just let them wreak havoc on each other. The shtick is old and we know what's coming, but in a world where Full House gets rebooted, I'm glad IASIP exists to remind us that sitcoms were always just 22-minute slices of sociopathy.
Plus, y'know, if you're going to satirize Trump, do it right.
Oh well. Bring on Game of Thrones and Daredevil. (Has anyone written a Weredevil AU? I'd be disappointed with fandom otherwise.)
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2016-03-13 10:15 am (UTC)Absolutely. But at the very least they knew which emotion they were manipulating. They didn't expect fans to just go "Awww, that's sad."
The ratings [for the next episode] were way down... the showrunner's number of Twitter followers went off a cliff
Awesome. That's the sort of stuff they care about.
And the "We had to kill her off since the actress had been cast in another show" would have been a lot more convincing if they hadn't already written her out at the end of s2, and brought her back for this...
no subject
Date: 2016-03-15 10:17 pm (UTC)I did not know that. Wow.